Multidimensional Assessment Multidimensional Assessment and Policy Strategies for Enhancing Sustainable Urban Agriculture in Makassar, Indonesia
Abstract
Urban agriculture (UA) can be described as a strategy of sustainable urban development that has the potential to combine ecological conservation, food security, and socio-economic resilience. The objective of this study is to evaluate the multidimensional sustainability of UA in Makassar City, Indonesia, and to formulate a policy framework to enhance its sustainability. The data presented herein were collected via expert discussions and semi-structured interviews with 23 purposively selected stakeholders, including academics, practitioners, urban planners, legislators, and government officials. Multidimensional Scaling (MDS) was utilised to derive sustainability indices, complemented by prospective and interdependence analyses to identify leverage points for policy intervention. The overall sustainability index during the specified period (2016-2020) was classified as "less sustainable" (43.02%). While the environmental (51.84%) and technological (65.09%) dimensions demonstrated an improvement, categorising as "moderately sustainable", the economic (46.15%), social (49.81%), and institutional (39.20%) dimensions exhibited a decline. The following key policy recommendations are proposed: first, the enhancement of planning and management systems; secondly, the optimisation of coordination among institutions; and thirdly, the optimisation of the social, economic and environmental functions of UA. The findings of this study provide empirical evidence for policy makers to design integrated, context-specific strategies for sustainable UA in tropical cities.
References
References
Abdullah (2016). Sustainability Index and Model of Environmental Behaviour in Urban Farming Development: a Case of Community of Makassar City. Post Graduade Disertasion of Universitas Negeri Makassar. (in Indonesian). https://lib.unm.ac.id/layanan/karya-ilmiah/tingkat-keberlanjutan-dan-model-perilaku-masyarakat-dalam-pengembangan-sistem-pertanian-perkotaan-urban-farming-di-kota-makassar
Abdullah, Haris, A., & Boceng, A. (2019). Community Perception and Behavior Patterns in Urban Agriculture Development as an Effort to Strengthen the Family Food Security System: A Case Study of Makassar City, South Sulawesi. Proceedings of the National Seminar in the Context of the 43rd UNS Anniversary, 3(1), 29–37.(in Indonesian). https://www.academia.edu/106838599/Persepsi_dan_Pola_Perilaku_Masyarakat_dalam_Pengembangan_Pertanian_Perkotaan_sebagai_Upaya_Memperkuat_Sistem_Ketahanan_Pangan_Keluarga_Studi_Kasus_Kota_Makassar_Sulawesi_Selatan
Ahmed, J., Woubishet, D. and Semereabc, E. (2024). The Role and Potential of Urban Agriculture: Exploratory Research. Final report ETH-23097, February 2024. Addis Ababa. https://www.theigc.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/Ahmed%20et%20al.%20Final%20Report%20October%202024.pdf
Altieri, M.A. & Nicholls, C. I. (2020). Agroecology and the reconstruction of a postCOVID-19 agricul. Journal of Peasant Studies, 47(5), 881–898.
https://doi.org/10.1080/03066150.2020.1782891
Armansyah, A., Soetrisno, A.L., Zaelany, A.A., Setiawan, B., Saputra, D., Haqi, M., Lamijo, L., Giyarsih, S.R., Fathurohman, A. (2024). Urban Farming as an Alternative in Realizing Sustainable City Development in Indonesia. Jurnal Kawistara: The Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, Vol.14, No.1, April 2024: 38-57. https://doi.org/10.22146/kawistara.84324
Barthel, S., Isendahl, C., Benyamin, N. Vis., Drescher, A., Evans, N., and Timmeren, A. (2019). Global urbanization and food production in direct competition for land: laverage places to mitigate impact on SDG2 and on the earth system. The Anthropocene Review 2019, Vol. 6(1-2) 71–97. Article reuse guidelines: sagepub.com/journals-permissions. http://doi.org/10.1177/2053019619856672.
Bhattarai, K., & Adhikari, A. P. (2023). Promoting Urban Farming for Creating Sustainable Cities in Nepal. Urban Sci. 2023, 7, 54, 1-28. https://doi.org/10.3390/urbansci7020054
[BPS] Statistics of Makassar Municipality. (2024). Kota Makassar dalam Angka-Makassar/ Municipality in Figures 2023. BPS Kota Makassar/BPS-Statistics of Makassar Municipality. Pp. 462. (in Indonesian).
Bourgeois, R. & Jesus, F. (2004). Participatory Prospective Analysis, Exploring and Anticipating Challenges with Stakeholders. Center for Alleviation of Poverty through Secondery Crops Development in Asia and The Pacific and French Agricultural Research Center for International Development. Monograph 46:1 – 29.
https://doi.org/10.22004/ag.econ.32731. https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/32731
Budiharjo, E. (2015). An introduction to a humane and environmentally conscious city. In: Takashi Inoguchi, Edward Newman, Glen Paoletto. (eds) Cities and Environments: A New Approach to an Ecologically Conscious Society. Jakarta: LP3ES. hlm. ix - xiv. (in Indonesian). https://inlislite-perpusbungkarno.perpusnas.go.id/opac/detail-opac?id=42410
Caputo, S., Schoen, V., & Blythe, C. (2023). Productivity and efficiency of community
gardens: Case studies from the UK. Land, 12, 238. https://doi.org/10.3390/land12010238
Chimbwanda, F. (2016). Perceptions and attitudes of participation toward urban gardening: A case study of nutrition gardens in Mucheke town, Masvingo. Civil and Environmental Research, 8(8), 59–63. https://iiste.org/Journals/index.php/CER/article/viewFile/32325/33213
Coskun, H. (2023). Eco-City Planning; concepts and contemporary models. Glob J Ecol 8(2): 110-119. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/gje.000090.
De Zeeuw, Henk. (2011). Cities, climate change and urban agriculture. Urban Agriculture Magazine 25: 39–42. https://www.scribd.com/document/604847078/cities-climate-change-and-urban-agriculture
Dewi, E.P., Trikariastoto, S.T., Kabul, E.R., Nurina, Swartane, I.G.A., Prijasembada. (2023). Integrated Urban Farming Park: Implementing Permaculture Design Concept for Child Education of Agriculture in Jakarta. The 6th International Conference on Eco Engineering Development 2022 (ICEED 2022). IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/1169/1/012057.
Eiter, S., Fjellstad, W. and Van Schaik, L. (2025). Monitoring sustainability of urban agriculture: Who is going to do it and how?. Landscape and Urban Planning 257, 1-12, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2025.105300
[FAO]Food and Agriculture Oganisation. (2025). Urban and peri-urban agriculture: Strengthening urban and periurban agriculture towards sustainable agrifood systems. https://www.fao.org/urban-peri-urban-agriculture/en
Fei, S., Wu, R., Liu, H., Yang, F., and Wang, N. (2025). Technological Innovations in Urban and Peri-Urban Agriculture: Pathways to Sustainable Food Systems in Metropolises. Horticulturae, 11(2), 212. https://doi.org/10.3390/horticulturae11020212
Gomez-Villarino, M.T., and Ruiz-Garcia, L. (2021). Adaptive design model for the integration of urban agriculture in the sustainable development of cities. A case study in northern Spain. In Sustainable Cities and Society, 65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2020.102595
Gray L., Elgert L., & Winkler, P. A. (2020). Theorizing urban agriculture: North–south convergence. Agriculture and Human Values, 37(3), 869–883. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-020-10015-x
Grover, H. and Wahee, S. (2013). Sustainability Through Urban Farming: A Case Study on Priyanka Amar Shah - Woman Ecopreneur. International Journal of Retailing & Rural Business Perspectives © Pezzottaite Journals. Volume 2, Number 3, July – September 2013: 600 – 603. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=aRs71rEAAAAJ&citation_for_view=aRs71rEAAAAJ:9yKSN-GCB0IC
Güneralp, B., Reba, M., Hales, B. U., Wentz, E. A., & Seto, K. C. (2020). Trends in urban
land expansion, density, and land transitions from 1970 to 2010: A global synthesis.
Environ Res Lett, 15, Article 044015. DOI: 10.1088/1748-9326/ab6669
Hallett, S., Hoagland, L., & Toner, E. (2016). Urban agriculture: Environmental, economic, and social perspectives. In Horticultural Reviews (Vol. 44, Issue November). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119281269.ch2
Hanifa, A.P., Yuniarsih, E.T., Qomariah, R., Nurmalinda, Saleh, Y., Haryati, Y., Lestari, I.P. and Lesmayati, S. (2023). Perspective Chapter: How Important is Urban Farming in Indonesia to Support Food Sovereignty? Eds. Ali Kuden and Burhanettin Imrak: Urban Horticulture-Sustainable Gardening in Cities. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.1001601
Hidayanto, M. (2010). Increasing sustainable land productivity for smallholder cocoa plantations in the East Kalimantan-Malaysia border area (Case Study on Sebatik Island, Nunukan Regency, East Kalimantan Province). Dissertation, Postgraduate School, IPB, Bogor. (in Indonesian) DOI: 10.21082/jae.v27n2.2009.213-229
Horst, M., McClintock, N., & Hoey, L. (2017). The Intersection of planning, urban agriculture, and food justice: A review of the literature. Journal of the American Planning Association, 83, 277–295. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944363.2017.1322914
Hume I. V., Summers D. M., & Cavagnaro T. R. (2021). Self-sufficiency through urban agriculture: Nice idea or plausible reality?. Sustainable Cities and Society, 68, Article 102770. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.102770
Ilieva, R.T., Cohen, N., Israel, M., Specht, K., Fox-Kämper, R., Fargue-Lelièvre, A., Poni?zy, L., Schoen, V., Caputo, S., Kirby, C.K., Goldstein, B., Newell, J.P. and Chris Blythe (2022). The Socio-Cultural Benefits of Urban Agriculture: A Review of the Literature. Land 11,1-21. https://doi.org/10.3390/land11050622
Indraprahasta, G. S. (2013). The potential of urban agriculture development in Jakarta. The 3rd International Conference on Sustainable Future for Human Security, SUSTAIN 2012. Procedia Environmental Sciences 17, 11 – 19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proenv.2013.02.006
Jasionkowski, R. and Czarnecka, A.L. (2017). The potential of urban agriculture for sustainability of cities in Poland. Ecological Questions 24/2016: 59 – 64. https://doi.org/10.12775/EQ.2016.012
Karyanto, P. (2012). Building Environmentally Aware Community Behavior. 9th National Seminar on Biology Education, Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, University of Surabaya, 2012: Biology, Science, the Environment, and Their Learning in Efforts to Increase National Competitiveness, 19 – 28. (in Indonesian) https://media.neliti.com/media/publications/172973-ID-membangun-perilaku-masyarakat-arif-lingk.pdf
Khosravi, S., Lashgarara, F., Poursaeed, A., & Omidi, N. M. (2022). Modeling the relationship between urban agriculture and sustainable development: A case study in Tehran city. Arabian Journal of Geosciences, 15(1), 97. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12517-021-09396-y.
Langemeyer, J., Madrid-Lopez, C., Mendoza Beltran, A., & Villalba Mendez, G. (2021). Urban agriculture — A necessary pathway towards urban resilience and global sustainability? Landscape and Urban Planning, 210, 104055.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2021.104055
Le?nicki, M. and Lewandowska, A. (2014). Implementation of sustainable development on the example ofthe concept of eco-city. Ecological Questions 19/2014: 91 – 96. DOI: 10.12775/EQ.2014.010
Orsini, F., Pennisi, G., Michelon, N., Minelli, A., Bazzocchi, G., Sanyé-Mengual, E. and Gianquinto, G. (2020). Features and Functions of Multifunctional Urban Agriculture in the Global North: A Review. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems. Vol. 4, 1-27.
http://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2020.562513
Papanek, A., Campbell, C. G., & Wooten, H. (2023). Social and Community Benefits and Limitations of Urban Agriculture: FCS3378/FY1517, 1/2023. EDIS, 2023(1). https://doi.org/10.32473/edis-fy1517-2023 https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FY1519
Parvin, S. and Islam, Md., S. (2023). Citizens'attitude And Perception Toward Rooftop Gardening In City Area. Khulna University Studies Special Issue ICSSI: 59-67. DOI: 10.53808/KUS.SI.2023.ICSSI46-ss
Popartan L.A., Pueyo-Ros J., Cassú E., Pointelin R., Castellar J., Comas, J. (2023). Chapter 14. ‘I Don’t Care about Tomatoes’: Building Situated Urban Commons in Girona. In: Edwards F., Popartan L.A., Pettersen I. ed. Urban Natures: Living the More-than-Human City. New York, Oxford: Berghahn Books, pp. 224-236. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781805390831-020.
Pradhan, P., Callaghan, M., Yuanchao Hu, Dahal, K., Hunecke, C., Reusswig, F., Lotze-Campen, H., and Kropp, J.P. (2023). A systematic review highlights that there are multiple benefits of urban agriculture besides food. Global Food Security, Vol. 38, September 2023, 100700. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gfs.2023.100700
Qasemi, M., Allahyari, M.S., Ben Hassen, T., Iman Askari, M. and El Bilali, H. (2023). Cultivating Change: Perceptions and Attitudes of Agricultural Experts towards the Sustainable Development Goals. Land 12, 1-14. https://doi.org/10.3390/land12081604
Ramadhan, B., & Sugihardjo, S. (2020). Public Participation in the Implementation of. In International Conference Labma Scientific Fair 2020, Yogyakarta. doi:10.20885/khazanah.vol12.iss2.art67
Russ, A. and Gaus, M. B. (2021). Urban Agriculture Education and Youth Civic Engagement in the U.S.: A Scoping Review. Social Movements, Institutions and Governance, Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems Journal, Vol.5, Article 707896, 1 – 8. https://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2021.707896
Sampeliling, S. (2012). Sustainable Urban Agricultural Development Policy Model (Case Study: DKI Jakarta Region). Dissertation of the Graduate School of Bogor Agricultural University (Unpublished). (in Indonesian). https://adoc.pub/model-kebijakan-pengembangan-pertanian-perkotaan-berkelanjut.html
Sampeliling, S., Sitorus, S. R. P., Siti Nurisyah, and Pramudya, B.(2012). Sustainable Urban Agriculture Development Policy: A case study in DKI Jakarta. J. Analisis Kebijakan. Vol. 10 No.3. September 2012: 257 – 267. (in Indonesian). http://doi.org/10.21082/akp.v10n3.2012.257-267
https://epublikasi.pertanian.go.id/berkala/akp/article/view/1032
Santoso, S. (2015). SPSS 22 from Essential to Expert Skills. Jakarta: Elex Media Komputindo. (in Indonesian).
Sbicca, J. (2019). Urban Agriculture, Revalorization, and Green Gentrification in Denver, Colorado. In T. Bartley (Ed.), The politics of land (pp. 149–170).
DOI: 10.1108/S0895-993520190000026011
Sebisibe, M. M. (2017). Determinants of Level of Women Participation in Urban Agriculture: The Case of Wolaita Sodo Town, Southern Region of Ethiopia. International Journal of African and Asian Studies, Vol. 35: 40 – 48. https://www.iiste.org/tag/international-journal-of-african-and-asian-studies-research-articles/
Serbessa, H., Makonnen, T. and Abi, M. (2023). The Contribution Of Urban Agriculture To Household Food Security Among Urban Vegetable Producers In Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Journal of Sustainable Development in Africa, Vol. 25, No.1, 93-113. https://jsd-africa.com/Jsda/2023%20V25%20NO1%20Spring/The%20Contribution%20of%20Urban%20Agriculture%20to%20Household_Habtamu%20Serbessa.pdf
Simon-Rojo, M., Recasens, X., Callau S., Du?zí, B., Eiter, S., Hern´andez, J. V., Kettle, P.,
Laviscio, R., Lohrberg, F., Pickard, D., Scazzosi, L., & Cavallo, A. (2015). From Urban Food Gardening to Urban Farming. In F. Lohrberg, L. Licka, L. Scazzosi, & A. Timpe (Eds.), Urban Agriculture Europe (pp. 22–28). Berlin, Germany: Jovis Verlag GmbH. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303843763_From_Urban_Food_Gardening_to_Urban_Farming
Ulfa, T. and Pertiwi, N. (2020). The Influence of Community Knowledge, Attitudes and Behavior on Urban Farming Activities. UNM Environmental J., Vol.4 No.1 Desember 2020 hal. 31 – 41. (in Indonesian). https://ojs.unm.ac.id/UEJ/article/view/22536
Specht, K., Siebert, R., Hartmann, I., Freisinger, U.B., Sawicka, M., Werner, A., Thomaier, S., D. Henckel, Walk, H., Dierich, A. (2014). Urban agriculture of the future: an overview of sustainabilityaspects of food production in and on buildings. Agric Hum Values (2014) 31:33–51. http://DOI.org./10.1007/s10460-013-9448-4
Tapia, C., Randall, L., Wang, S., Aguiar, B.L. (2021). Monitoring the contribution of urban agriculture to urban sustainability: An indicator-based framework. Sustainable Cities and Society, 74 (2021), Article 103130. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.103130
United Nations Development Programme. (March, 2025). Goal 11: Sustainable Cities and Communities. Make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable. https://www.unep.org/topics/sustainable-development-goals/why-do-sustainable-development-goals-matter/goal-11-0. https://www.undp.org/sustainable-development-goals/sustainable-cities-and-communities.
Walters, S. A., & Midden, K. S. (2018). Sustainability of Urban Agriculture: vegetable production on green roofs. Agriculture 8:168. http://doi.org/10.3390/agriculture8110168
Wiskerke, J. S. C. (2020). Creating a supportive public policy framework for urban agriculture. Eds. Johannes S. C. Wiskerke. Achieving sustainable urban agriculture. Pp. 3 – 21. Published by Burleigh Dodds Science Publishing Limited. 82 High Street, Sawston, Cambridge CB22 3HJ, UK. www.bdspublishing.com
Wisneni, A., Abdullah, A., & Boceng, A. (2021). Sustainability of Garden Alley Development in Realizing an Environmentally Friendly Urban Area (Eco City) in Makassar. AGROTEK: Jurnal Ilmiah Ilmu Pertanian, 4(2), 10–23. (in Indonesian). https://jurnal.fp.umi.ac.id/index.php/agrotek/article/view/136
Yalew, A. (2020). Urban Agriculture in Ethiopia: An overview. Regional Economic Development Research, 1(2), pp. 85–92. http://doi.org/10.37256/redr.122020607
Yan, D., Liu, L., Liu, X., Zhang, M. (2022). Global Trends in Urban Agriculture Research: A Pathway toward Urban Resilience and Sustainability. Land 2022, 11, 117, 1 – 17. https://doi.org/10.3390/land11010117, https://www.mdpi.com/journal/land
Yuan, G. N., Marquez, G.P.B., Deng, H., Lu, A., Fabella, M., Reginald, B. Salonga, Ashardiono, F., Cartagena, J.A. (2022). A review on urban agriculture: technology, socio-economy, and policy. Heliyon 8 (2022) e11583. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e11583
Zainal, M. & Hamzah, S.R. (2017). Urban Agriculture: The Role of Knowledge among Farmer in Malaysia. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. Vol. 7, Special Issue - 4th International Conference on Educational Research and Practice. ISSN: 2222-6990. 77 – 85. http://Doi.org/10.6007/IJARBSS/v7-i14/3653